Robert Parker i Bordeaux Book, 3rd Edition B1 Jan 1998
“The 1990 Margaux continues to be the quintessential example of this chateau. In addition to being
profoundly concentrated, its ethereal bouquet of sweet black fruits, cedar, spices, flowers, smoke, and
vanilla is remarkably well-formed and intense. In the mouth, there is not a hard edge to this classic wine,
which is super-concentrated, soft, silky-textured, and opulent. It displays an opaque ruby/purple color, a
compelling bouquet, and exquisite layers of flavors that cascade over the palate without any notion of
toughness or coarseness. The acidity is low, although sufficient enough to provide vibrancy and focus. This
wine’s significant tannin level is remarkably well-concealed by the wealth of fruit. Although still an infant
in terms of development, this fabulous Margaux is already drinkable. There have been so many great
vintages of Margaux under the Mentzelopoulos regime that it is almost inconceivable that the 1990 could
outrank the 1982, 1983, 1985, 1986, and 1995, but, in my opinion, it possesses an extra-special dimension.
While it is approachable, it will last for 25-30 years. Last tasted 11/96. Drink 1996-2026”
100 Point
Robert parker i The Wine Advocate 109 Feb 1997
“For me, the 1990 Margaux continues to be the quintessential example of this chateau. In addition to
being profoundly concentrated, its ethereal bouquet of sweet black fruits, cedar, spices, flowers, smoke,
and vanilla is remarkably well-formed and intense. In the mouth, there is not a hard edge to this classic
wine, which is super-concentrated, soft, silky-textured, and opulent. It displays an opaque ruby/purple
color, a compelling bouquet, and exquisite layers of flavors that cascade over the palate without any
notion of toughness or coarseness. The acidity is low, although sufficient enough to provide vibrancy and
focus. This wine’s significant tannin level is remarkably well-concealed by the wealth of fruit. Although still
an infant in terms of development, this fabulous Margaux is already drinkable. There have been so many
great vintages of Margaux under the Mentzelopoulos regime that it is almost inconceivable that the
1990 could outrank the 1982, 1983, 1985, 1986, and 1995, but, in my opinion, it possesses an extra-special
dimension. While it is approachable, it will last for 25-30 years. Drink 1997-2020.”
100 Point
Robert Parker i The Wine Advocate 95 Oct 1994
“Tasted 7 Times Since Bottling With Consistent Notes More than any other recent vintage, the 1990 reminds
me of what Chateau Margaux’s classic 1953 might have tasted like at age three. Not a heavyweight
in the style of their 1982, the 1990 exhibits an ethereal bouquet of flowers, cassis, smoke, new oak,
and oriental spices. The tannins are significant but tender, and the wine is expansive, with remarkable
finesse, richness, and a smooth-as-silk finish. The wine’s exceptional richness and harmony are hallmarks.
This vintage gets my nod as the most classic example of Margaux made under the Menzelopoulos
administration. 1990 is a majestic vintage for Chateau Margaux, as well as one of the greatest wines of this
superb vintage. Anticipated maturity: 1997-2020.”
100 Point
Robert Parker i The Wine Advocate 88 Aug 1993
“More than any other recent vintage, the 1990 reminds me of what Chateau Margaux’s classic 1953 might
have tasted like at age three. Not a heavyweight in the style of their 1982, the 1990 exhibits an ethereal
bouquet of flowers, cassis, smoke, new oak, and oriental spices. The tannins are significant but tender, and
the wine is expansive, with remarkable finesse, richness, and a smooth-as-silk finish. The wine’s exceptional
richness and harmony are hallmarks. This vintage gets my nod as the most classic example of Margaux
made under the Mentzelopoulos administration. 1990 is a majestic vintage for Chateau Margaux, as well
as one of the greatest wines of this superb vintage. Anticipated maturity: 1997-2020. Last tasted, 8/93.”
100 Point
Robert Parker i The Wine Advocate 85 Feb 1993
(Her blev lovprisningen gentaget i Aug 1993 så den har vi udeladt)
100 Point
in typischer Margaux ist das nicht, was da 1990 auf die Flasche kam. Dreimal habe ich diesen Wein als 100-Punkte-Stoff erlebt, alle drei Vorstellungen waren im Jahr 2000, was eine seltsame Analogie zu meinen Erlebnissen mit Latour zeigt. Auf der großen 89/90 Verkostung ein wunderbares Teil, perfekt, harmonisch, seidig – 100/100. Einen Monat später auf einer weiteren Probe dichtes Powerteil, Korinthen, Rumtopf, auch am Gaumen Kraft ohne Ende, überreifes, untypisches Geschoss - 100/100. Und noch einen Monat später im Spago in Las Vegas Traumstoff, nicht ganz so korinthig, deutlich jünger, aber trotzdem eine opulente Sau, irre!!! - 100/100. Und damit war das Feuerwrk vorerst abgebrannt. Dreimal in 2001 präsentierte sich der Margaux recht verschlossen. Erst 2006 kam wieder mehr, die modernere Variante der berühmten Eisenfaust im Samthandschuh, durch die sich große Margaux früherer Jahre auszeichneten. Immer noch recht verschlossen, lässt seine Größe aber erahnen, sehr fruchtig, intensiv, dicht und lang. Bei aller Kraft aber elegant und fein strukturiert. Da sind heute schon 96+/100 im Glas, das Potential für 98/100 hat er. In 2007 zweimal total verschlossen und dann im Herbst 2007 auf René Gabriels großer Margaux-Probe: Ein unglaublich offener, hedonistischer Wein mit geiler Nase, viel Süße, fast exotisch und kalifornisch anmutend, aber auch mit zu wenig Rückrat. Ein klassischer 90er eben, der wohl in dieser Form in den nächsten Jahren getrunken gehört. Für einen Margaux mag er etwas banal wirken, Riesenspaß macht er trotzdem - 97/100 (Quelle: wineterminator.com Dr. Becker).